How Gift Cards And Loyalty Rewards Support Repeat Sales

Gift cards and loyalty programs are often filed under "nice to have" — features that signal brand maturity without a clear revenue return. The data tells a different story. According to First Data's gift card consumer research, 72% of gift card recipients spend more than the card's value when they redeem it, and 75% of those recipients visit a store they hadn't shopped at before receiving the card. Loyalty programs, when structured correctly, drive similar outcomes: customers enrolled in loyalty programs spend 12–18% more per year than non-enrolled customers, according to Bond Brand Loyalty's annual report.

Neither mechanism works passively. A gift card sitting unredeemed in a wallet generates no revenue. A loyalty program that only rewards purchases with delayed discounts generates minimal behavioral change. The stores that generate real repeat sales from these tools have designed them as active retention systems rather than passive perks. On Shopify, both are implementable natively or through the app ecosystem — the strategic layer is what most stores are missing.

How Gift Cards Drive New and Repeat Revenue

Gift cards serve two distinct revenue functions that are often conflated. The first is acquisition: a gift card introduces your store to someone who hasn't bought from you before — the recipient. The second is retention: the act of buying a gift card deepens the purchasing customer's commitment to the brand, and the redemption event creates a high-intent purchase moment for the recipient.

Three specific revenue mechanisms gift cards generate:

• Breakage revenue. According to CEB (now Gartner) research, approximately 10–19% of gift card value is never redeemed — this unredeemed balance is recorded as revenue by the issuing store. For high-volume gift card programs, breakage contributes meaningfully to margin without any associated product or fulfillment cost.
• Overspend at redemption. First Data's research finding that 72% of recipients spend more than card value is a consistently replicated pattern across retail categories. A customer redeeming a $50 gift card who spends $74 has been introduced to your store at effectively zero acquisition cost and converted at above-average order value on the first visit.
• Triggered reactivation. Gift cards sent as win-back offers to lapsed customers — "Here's $15 credit, come back and see what's new" — reactivate customers who haven't responded to standard promotional emails. The perceived value of a gift card offer differs psychologically from a discount code: it feels like receiving something rather than being offered a price reduction.

Setting Up Gift Cards on Shopify

Shopify includes gift card functionality on all paid plans. The setup is straightforward, but the configuration decisions that most stores overlook are what determine whether gift cards become a retention driver or just an order option.

1. Enable gift cards in Shopify Admin → Products → Gift cards. Set denominations that match your average order value — a $25 denomination in a store with a $65 AOV creates a predictable overspend dynamic. A $100 denomination in the same store creates a barrier to gifting.
2. Set the expiry policy deliberately. Shopify allows gift cards with no expiry or a set expiry date. No-expiry cards have higher redemption rates and generate more goodwill; expiry-date cards create urgency but also friction and customer complaints. Most merchants benefit from no-expiry or 2-year expiry as a default.
3. Enable digital delivery. Shopify's native gift card emails are functional but basic. The email is often the recipient's first impression of your brand — it's worth customising the template to match your store's visual identity and include a brief message about what makes your products worth choosing.
4. Create gift card-specific landing pages for gifting occasions. A dedicated "Gift Cards" collection page that ranks for "[your category] gift card" or "[your brand] gift" captures search traffic from people looking for gifting options in your category — traffic that has high purchase intent and zero existing brand awareness requirements.

Loyalty Program Structures and Which Ones Retain Customers

Not all loyalty program structures produce the same retention outcomes. The type that most stores default to — points for purchases, redeemable as discounts — has the weakest retention effect of the common formats because it operates as a delayed price reduction rather than a relationship-building mechanism.

According to Yotpo's 2025 loyalty benchmark data, loyalty program members generate 39% more revenue per year than non-members on average. The programs with the highest member revenue are those with tiered structures and non-purchase earning actions — not simple points-for-purchases systems.

Designing Rewards That Actually Change Behaviour

The test for whether a loyalty reward will change customer behaviour is simple: would a customer who is deciding between your store and a competitor choose yours specifically because of this reward? If the answer is no — if the reward is too small, too delayed, or too similar to what a competitor offers — it won't drive retention.

Reward design principles that produce behavioural change:

• Make the first reward reachable quickly. According to Smile.io's loyalty data, 70% of customers who never reach their first reward redemption disengage from the program within 60 days. Structure the lowest reward tier so a new customer can reach it on their second or third order — not after 10 purchases.
• Offer rewards that can't be purchased elsewhere. Early access to new products, members-only bundles, exclusive colourways, or access to a VIP community are rewards that competitors can't directly match with a discount. These create brand-specific value that cash-equivalent discounts don't.
• Communicate progress clearly. Customers who know exactly how close they are to the next reward are more likely to make a purchase to reach it. According to Smile.io's consumer research, showing progress toward a reward in post-purchase emails increases click-through rates by 41% compared to emails without progress indicators.
• Time limited-bonus point events to drive off-peak purchasing. Double-points events during typically slow periods pull forward purchases that would have happened later — or might not have happened at all — by creating urgency through the loyalty program rather than through discounting.

Using Gift Cards and Loyalty Together

The most effective retention setups treat gift cards and loyalty rewards as complementary mechanisms rather than separate programs. Several combinations produce measurable outcomes:

• Award loyalty points on gift card purchases. The customer who buys a gift card for someone else earns points — incentivising gift card buying and deepening the purchasing customer's loyalty simultaneously.
• Allow loyalty points redemption as store credit. Converting points to store credit (rather than percent-off discounts) creates an asset the customer has to come back to use — reinforcing return visits more effectively than a one-time discount code.
• Send gift cards as loyalty tier upgrade rewards. When a customer reaches a new loyalty tier, a surprise gift card — even $10–$15 — creates a moment of positive surprise that activates the reciprocity effect more strongly than simply updating their status label.
• Use gift card credit as a win-back offer for loyalty program members who've lapsed. A lapsed loyalty member who receives store credit tied to their existing account has a specific reason to return — they have value waiting for them. This approach reactivates members without requiring a discount on the next purchase.

Measuring Whether Your Program Is Working

The metrics that matter for gift card and loyalty program performance are not the same as the metrics for acquisition campaigns. Tracking them separately is what allows you to see whether the retention investment is producing real revenue lift.

Key metrics to track per month:

• Gift card redemption rate: the percentage of issued gift card value that has been redeemed. A rate above 80% indicates active use; below 60% suggests the cards are being purchased but not effectively prompting return visits.
• Average overspend at gift card redemption: the average amount spent above gift card value. Tracking this per denomination reveals which card values create the most overspend — a useful data point for optimising default denominations.
• Loyalty program member repeat purchase rate vs. non-member repeat purchase rate: this is the core metric for whether the program is doing its job. According to Yotpo's loyalty benchmarks, well-structured programs show a 39%+ revenue gap between members and non-members.
• Points redemption rate: the percentage of earned points that are redeemed. A redemption rate below 20% typically indicates either that the redemption threshold is too high or that the rewards aren't compelling enough to motivate return visits.

Try Shopify

Final Thoughts

Gift cards and loyalty rewards earn their place in a retention strategy when they're designed as active systems rather than passive perks. Gift cards that are configurable with meaningful denominations, clearly communicated expiry policies, and integrated with loyalty point earning turn a one-time purchase into a retention chain. Loyalty programs that reward engagement beyond purchases, offer status-based benefits that create loss aversion, and communicate progress toward rewards change customer behaviour in ways that discount programs alone don't.

The stores generating meaningful repeat revenue from these mechanisms share a common trait: they've thought carefully about what happens after the customer buys, not just about how to get the first purchase. That orientation — treating retention as a system rather than an afterthought — is what separates brands with high customer lifetime value from those perpetually dependent on acquisition spend.

Setting up gift cards and loyalty programs on Shopify gives you the infrastructure — the strategy layer is deciding what rewards actually motivate your specific customers to come back, and building the program around those motivations rather than around what's easiest to implement.

FAQ

Do Gift Cards Count as Revenue When Sold on Shopify?

In Shopify, gift card sales are recorded as a liability (deferred revenue) when sold and recognised as revenue when redeemed. Unredeemed balances that expire or are written off may be recognised as breakage revenue depending on your accounting treatment — consult your accountant for the treatment applicable in your jurisdiction.

What Is a Good Points Redemption Rate for a Loyalty Program?

Above 30% indicates an engaging program where customers value the rewards enough to return for them. Below 20% typically signals that either the reward threshold is too high or the rewards aren't compelling enough to drive return visits.

Should I Use Shopify's Native Loyalty Features or a Third-Party App?

Shopify's native gift card functionality covers most use cases without an app. For loyalty programs with points, tiers, and referral tracking, third-party apps like Smile.io, Yotpo Loyalty, or LoyaltyLion provide features Shopify doesn't offer natively. Start native and add an app when you need tiered or multi-action earning.

How Much Discount Should I Offer Through a Loyalty Program?

Structure rewards so that the effective discount rate is 3–7% of purchase value — enough to feel meaningful without significantly eroding margin. Programs offering over 10% effective discount tend to attract deal-seekers rather than loyal customers, which defeats the retention purpose.

We only recommend tools we've tested and trust. This post may include affiliate links, meaning we may earn a commission if you choose to purchase - at no extra cost to you.